Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra vs eufy X10 Pro Omni: Which Should You Buy?

The short answer

Buy the eufy X10 Pro Omni. It scores 8.2 to the Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra's 8.8, and for most households that six-tenths of a point is not worth what it costs. The eufy cleans like a machine from a bracket above its own, its dock does all four of the jobs a dock should do, and it is quiet enough that you can leave it running while you are in the room.

Buy the Roborock if one of three specific things is true of your home: you have a lot of medium-pile carpet, your floors are never actually clear (toys, cables, shoes), or you want the best pet-hair pickup that exists and are willing to pay for the last few percent. It is the better machine. It is comfortably the better machine. The question is whether it is better by as much as it costs, and in most houses the honest answer is no.

One thing to check before you decide anything: the price gap between these two varies a lot by country and by whatever discounting is running that week. In some regions the eufy is roughly half the Roborock. In others they are much closer, and if they are close in yours, the calculation flips and you should just buy the Roborock. Check both listings before you take our word for the value argument.

At a glance

Two rows there do most of the work. The noise row is the eufy's best argument, and the app row is its worst.

Where the Roborock genuinely wins

Pet hair. Independent testing puts the Roborock at roughly 99% pet-hair pickup by weight, which is about as good as robot vacuums get. The dual rubber rollers are designed to resist tangling, which is the failure mode that ruins most robots in a home with a shedding dog. If pet hair is the reason you are buying at all, read our best robot vacuums for pet hair guide, because that is a case where paying more actually buys you something.

Cluttered floors. Reactive AI 2.0 obstacle avoidance is the feature people underrate until they own a robot. If you have children, or a hallway that collects charging cables, the difference between a robot that goes around things and a robot that eats them is the difference between a machine you use and a machine you stop bothering with. The eufy has its own strength here, which is that its cliff detection is reliable: it stops hard at stairs and marks them as no-go. What Roborock adds on top of that is the ability to recognise and steer around the things on your floor.

The dock. Both docks empty, wash, dry and refill. The Roborock's is the most complete self-maintaining system available, with a hot mop wash and heated drying. That is not a spec-sheet flourish. Damp mop pads sitting in a dock are exactly how these things start to smell, which we cover in why your robot vacuum dock smells.

Where the eufy wins

Noise. At around 57 to 58 dB in normal use, you can talk over the eufy. The Roborock at full suction is 74 dB, and you will go to another room. This changes how you actually use the machine. A quiet robot runs in the evening while you are on the sofa; a loud one only runs when the house is empty, which means it runs less often, which means your floors are dirtier. Owners bring this up constantly and spec sheets bury it.

Mopping on carpet. The eufy's dual spinning mops press down hard and lift 12 mm, which is enough to keep carpets dry. Counter-intuitively the Roborock's larger 20 mm lift is part of why it struggles on thick high-pile carpet: the mop can drag damp fur across the pile.

Value. Reviewers are close to unanimous that this is flagship capability for well under flagship money. That is the whole case for it, and it is a strong one.

Be honest: both of these have real flaws

The Roborock is expensive, and reviewers say so consistently. Thick high-pile carpet is its weakest surface. Deeply embedded dirt in medium-pile carpet needs several passes before it comes up. The dock is large, it is loud at maximum suction, and it will build up odours if you neglect it. That last one is not a defect so much as a maintenance job you are signing up for, and people who ignore it end up with a machine that smells.

The eufy's app is the weak point, and we would not soften that. It is buggy, laggy and less polished than what Roborock ships. You cannot draw your own virtual walls in the map, which is genuinely annoying if you have one room you always want excluded. The base station is very large and cannot really be hidden, so measure the space you have in mind before you commit. The front brush is less effective than rivals on fine debris on hard floors, and the mopping leaves a slight sheen rather than a dry finish.

So which house are you?

Mostly hard floors, some rugs, normal amount of mess. eufy. You will not notice the missing 2,000 Pa, and you will notice the quiet every single day.

Medium-pile carpet through most of the house, or a heavy-shedding pet. Roborock. This is the case it was built for and where the extra suction and the anti-tangle rollers earn their keep.

Thick, high-pile carpet everywhere. Be careful. The Roborock is the higher-scoring machine, but high-pile is the one surface where it convinces reviewers least. Neither of these is an ideal buy for you.

You care about the app. Roborock, with no argument. The 3D mapping and room-specific cleaning are good, and the eufy's app is the single thing most likely to make you regret the purchase.

You have a small flat and nowhere obvious to put a dock. Look hard at the eufy's base station dimensions on the listing first. It is a big object, and so is the Roborock's. There is no small answer in this comparison.

Our call

The eufy X10 Pro Omni is what we recommend to most people, and the 8.2 reflects a machine that gets you most of the way to a flagship for a lot less. The Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra at 8.8 is the better robot vacuum in almost every measurable way, and it is the right buy for pet owners, carpeted homes and cluttered floors. Both are honest scores. Neither is a trap.

Affiliate note. The links above are affiliate links and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How we research and score.