Product catalogue

Independent reviews of 20 smart home products, with links to the Amazon store for your region.

Amazon links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Scores are our own editorial ratings out of 10, not aggregated user reviews. How we research and score.

energy
ecobee
8.5 /10

ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium

The strongest smart thermostat for a North American heating system, and the one to buy if you want room sensors done properly. It is a 24VAC device for forced-air, heat pump and low-voltage boiler setups, so it is the right answer in the US and Canada and the wrong answer almost everywhere else.

Wiring
24VAC through C and Rc terminals; Power Extender Kit included for homes with no C wire
HVAC support
Furnace and AC to 2H/2C, heat pump 2H/2C with 2-stage aux, boilers, PTAC and fan coil
Sensors
Temperature, humidity, radar occupancy and proximity, air quality
In the box
Thermostat, SmartSensor, Power Extender Kit, trim plate, mounting hardware
energy
Drayton
7.9 /10

Drayton Wiser Smart Thermostat Kit 1 (Combi Boiler)

The best-value route into room-by-room heating control if you have a combi boiler and no interest in a monthly fee. Buy it for the zoning and the OpenTherm modulation, not for a slick app.

Typical price £130–£170

In the box
1-channel Wiser HubR with wallplate, Wiser Room Thermostat with bracket, thermostat stand, 2x AA batteries
Boiler type
Combi boilers (heating on one channel, hot water on demand)
Boiler interface
Relay (on/off) or OpenTherm
Zones
Up to 16 rooms and 63 Wiser devices, using Smart Radiator Thermostats sold separately
energy
TP-Link Tapo
7.9 /10

TP-Link Tapo P110 Mini Smart Wi-Fi Plug with Energy Monitoring

The default cheap smart plug for Alexa and Google homes, and the one to pick if you want a rough answer to what an appliance costs to run. Treat the energy figures as indicative, not metering. If you are on Apple Home, or you want Matter, buy the P110M instead.

Hub required
No. Connects directly to 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi
802.11b/g/n, 2.4 GHz only
Maximum load
13 A / 2990 W on the UK and Irish model. Check the rating on your region's version
Energy monitoring
Yes. Current draw plus 30-day and 12-month history
energy
Eve
7.8 /10

Eve Energy (Matter) Smart Plug

If you already have a Thread border router, this is the plug to buy and the trade-offs are mostly about money. If you do not, buy the hub first or buy a different plug, because the Matter version has no Bluetooth fallback and will not run without one.

Protocols
Matter over Thread (no Bluetooth, no Wi-Fi)
Hub required
Yes. A Thread border router, not included
Works with
Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings, Home Assistant
Power metering
Yes, with historical data and cost estimates
energy
tado°
7.5 /10

tado° Smart Thermostat X Starter Kit (Wired)

The best-engineered smart thermostat for a European boiler, and the one to pick if you want Matter and OpenTherm rather than another proprietary cloud. Price the subscription in before you buy, because the money-saving features are behind it.

Typical price £120–£160

In the box
Smart Thermostat X (wired), Bridge X (Thread border router), AAA batteries, mounting hardware
Connectivity
Matter over Thread
Boiler interface
Relay (on/off) or OpenTherm
Heating types
Boilers, heat pumps and water-based underfloor heating, per tado's compatibility checker
energy
Amazon
6.8 /10

Amazon Smart Plug

Buy it only if you are certain your home will stay Alexa-only. In that one case the setup really is trivial and it does the job. Everyone else is better served by a Kasa, Tapo or Meross plug that costs the same or less, works with every major platform, and actually reports how much power the thing is drawing.

Plug type
North American 2-pin (NEMA), 120 V. Not sold in a UK, Irish or European fitting
Max load
15 A at 120 V
Connectivity
Wi-Fi 2.4 GHz only
Hub required
No